%2Ffit-in%2F250x250%2Fguide_websites%2F184869%2Fimages%2F1790123067151bearcraftfishingsciencelogo.jpg&w=1920&q=100)
/users/68d642b6-c809-4f57-b879-8b4102e62829/ratecard/767190298_122179327994723337_5646957461528773354_n-mudcdcqx.jpg)
%2F300x300%2Fusers%2F68d642b6-c809-4f57-b879-8b4102e62829%2Fratecard%2F767190298_122179327994723337_5646957461528773354_n-mudcdcqx.jpg&w=256&q=75)
%2F300x300%2Fusers%2F68d642b6-c809-4f57-b879-8b4102e62829%2Fimages%2Fchinook-salmon-bayside-marina-catch-2573.jpg&w=256&q=75)
%2F300x300%2Fusers%2F68d642b6-c809-4f57-b879-8b4102e62829%2Fimages%2Fchinook-salmon-mexico-ny-catch-2458.jpg&w=256&q=75)
%2F300x300%2Fusers%2F68d642b6-c809-4f57-b879-8b4102e62829%2Fimages%2Ffishing-catch-mexico-ny-boat-2578.jpg&w=256&q=75)
%2F300x300%2Fusers%2F68d642b6-c809-4f57-b879-8b4102e62829%2Fimages%2Fstriped-bass-mexico-ny-catch-2466.jpg&w=256&q=75)
%2F300x300%2Fusers%2F68d642b6-c809-4f57-b879-8b4102e62829%2Fimages%2Fchinook-salmon-catch-mexico-ny-2716.jpg&w=256&q=75)
%2F300x300%2Fusers%2F68d642b6-c809-4f57-b879-8b4102e62829%2Fimages%2Fboat-docked-mexico-ny-lake-2571.jpg&w=256&q=75)
%2F300x300%2Fusers%2F68d642b6-c809-4f57-b879-8b4102e62829%2Fimages%2Fmexico-ny-chinook-salmon-catch-2804.jpg&w=256&q=75)
%2F300x300%2Fusers%2F68d642b6-c809-4f57-b879-8b4102e62829%2Fimages%2Fmexico-ny-chinook-salmon-catch-2478.jpg&w=256&q=75)
%2F300x300%2Fusers%2F68d642b6-c809-4f57-b879-8b4102e62829%2Fimages%2Flake-trout-mexico-ny-fishing-2403.jpg&w=256&q=75)
%2F300x300%2Fusers%2F68d642b6-c809-4f57-b879-8b4102e62829%2Fimages%2Fchinook-salmon-mexico-ny-catch-2563.jpg&w=256&q=75)
Evening Sunset Boat Fishing for Lake Ontario Salmon
Lake Ontario, NYWhat you will be catching:
Atlantic Salmon
Chinook Salmon
Coho Salmon
Lake Trout
Steelhead Trout
- Evening trolling sessions target trophy salmon during peak feeding hours
- Captain provides expert lure adjustments and low-light fishing tactics
- Comprehensive gear management with complimentary fish filleting service included
Trip Pricing and Availabilities:
Evening Sunset Boat Fishing for Lake Ontario Salmon
There's something magical about being on Lake Ontario as the sun starts to drop and the water turns glassy. Captain Forrest has been running these evening salmon charters for years, and he knows exactly when those big fish start moving up from the depths to feed. This isn't your typical all-day grind on the water – it's a focused, high-energy fishing experience that takes advantage of one of the best bite windows Lake Ontario has to offer. You'll be trolling prime salmon water just as the light fades, when trophy fish get active and your chances of hooking into something special go through the roof.
What to Expect on the Water
Captain Forrest picks you up right around the time most anglers are calling it quits for the day, which is exactly when the action heats up. Lake Ontario's salmon and trout species move shallow during these evening hours, following baitfish toward the surface as water temperatures drop. The boat holds up to four anglers, so you're not fighting for rod space or dealing with crowded conditions. As you head out, the captain sets up your spread with lures specifically chosen for low-light conditions – spoons, plugs, and cut bait that trigger aggressive strikes from feeding salmon. The atmosphere is relaxed but focused, with everyone watching their rod tips and listening for the screaming drag that signals a fish on. When the sun finally sets behind you, the water often lights up with jumping salmon and the kind of steady action that makes evening fishing legendary on this lake.
Trolling Tactics for Evening Bites
This trip is all about trolling, which means the boat stays in constant motion while your lines work different depths and distances behind the stern. Captain Forrest runs a mix of downriggers, planer boards, and lead core setups to cover the water column where salmon are most likely to be feeding. Evening trolling on Lake Ontario requires different lure choices than daytime fishing – darker colors and flashier presentations that fish can see and feel in diminishing light conditions. The captain handles all the technical stuff like setting depths, adjusting boat speed, and reading the fish finder, while you focus on working the rods and fighting fish. When a salmon hits, you'll know it immediately – these fish don't nibble, they slam the bait and take off on blistering runs that test your drag system and your arms. All gear is provided and maintained by Bear Craft Fishing Science LLC, from quality rods and reels to a full tackle selection that's proven effective on Lake Ontario salmon.
Species You'll Want to Hook
Atlantic Salmon are the crown jewel of Lake Ontario, and evening hours give you your best shot at hooking one of these legendary fighters. These fish typically run 15-25 pounds but can push well over 30, and they're known for spectacular aerial displays when hooked. Atlantics prefer cooler water temperatures, which is why evening fishing is so effective – they move up from deep haunts as the sun drops and water cools. What makes them special is their combination of size, strength, and acrobatic ability that leaves every angler who hooks one with stories to tell for years.
Coho Salmon are the acrobats of the Great Lakes, famous for their jumping ability and aggressive nature. These silver rockets typically range from 8-15 pounds and are absolute dynamite on the end of your line. Coho feed heavily during evening hours, often striking with such violence that they hook themselves before you even realize you have a bite. They're particularly active in late summer and early fall, making them a customer favorite during peak season. Their firm, pink meat makes them excellent table fare, and Captain Forrest will fillet your catch right at the dock so you can take home a fresh dinner.
Steelhead Trout are the marathon runners of Lake Ontario, capable of long, powerful runs that can empty your reel if you're not ready. These chrome-bright fish average 8-12 pounds but fight like they're twice that size. Steelhead are most active during cooler months and low-light conditions, making evening trips prime time for hooking into one. They're notorious for their unpredictable behavior – one minute they're bulldogging deep, the next they're clearing the water in spectacular jumps. Many anglers consider steelhead the ultimate light-tackle adversary because of their combination of speed, power, and stamina.
Chinook Salmon are the heavyweights of Lake Ontario, with mature fish commonly reaching 20-30 pounds and occasionally topping 40. These massive salmon prefer deep, cold water during the day but move shallow during evening feeding periods, putting them right in your wheelhouse. Chinooks are known for their raw power and ability to strip line off your reel in long, unstoppable runs. When you hook a big king salmon during the evening bite, you're in for a battle that can last 20 minutes or more. Their size and strength make them the most sought-after trophy in the lake, and landing one is a memory that lasts a lifetime.
Lake Trout are the deep-water specialists that often surprise anglers during evening trips when they move up to chase baitfish. These native predators can reach impressive sizes in Lake Ontario, with fish over 20 pounds caught regularly. Lakers are known for their dogged, deep-fighting style – they don't jump like salmon, but they use their bulk and strength to stay deep and make you work for every inch of line. Evening hours sometimes bring lake trout into shallower water where they're more accessible to trolling presentations, giving you a shot at one of the lake's most prized native species.
Time to Book Your Spot
Evening salmon fishing on Lake Ontario offers something you just can't get during daytime trips – cooler temperatures, calmer conditions, and fish that are actively feeding as the sun sets. Captain Forrest's evening charters with Bear Craft Fishing Science LLC give you access to some of the best salmon and trout fishing the Great Lakes have to offer, with professional guidance and top-quality gear
Learn more about the species
Atlantic Salmon
Atlantic salmon are sleek, silver-bodied fish that average 28-30 inches and 8-12 pounds in Lake Ontario. Unlike Pacific salmon, these fish can survive spawning and return multiple times, making them incredibly strong fighters. They prefer cooler water temperatures and will move up from deeper holds during evening hours to feed in the upper water column - perfect timing for our sunset trips. What makes atlantics special is their legendary jumping ability and sustained runs once hooked. The meat is premium quality with that classic orange-pink color. One key tip: when trolling for atlantics during low light, slow your presentation down slightly compared to daytime speeds. They're more cautious feeders than other salmon, so a subtle approach often triggers more strikes as the sun starts to set.
Chinook Salmon
Chinook are the kings of Lake Ontario - the biggest salmon species we target, commonly hitting 20-30 pounds with some pushing even larger. These silver-sided powerhouses have black spots covering their backs, fins, and distinctive black mouths. Kings are light-sensitive fish that typically hold in deeper water during the day, but evening hours bring them up to feed as darkness approaches. The fight is legendary - long, powerful runs that'll test your drag system. The meat is rich and oily with that deep orange-pink color. Best fishing happens from late spring through fall. Here's something most anglers don't know: kings often follow baits for long distances before striking. During evening trips, I'll sometimes slow the boat down even more than usual, letting those big fish get a really good look before they commit.
Coho Salmon
Coho salmon, also called silvers, are true acrobats that can jump up to 6 feet when hooked. These fish typically run 8-12 pounds in Lake Ontario, with their bright silver sides and distinctive black spots on the back and tail. They love to cruise the upper water layers during evening hours, making them perfect targets for our sunset trips. Coho are aggressive feeders and known for putting on aerial shows that'll get your heart pumping. The meat is bright orange-red and tastes amazing. During twilight hours, they become less spooky and more willing to chase lures. Here's a local trick: when coho are following your lure but not hitting, try dropping your rod tip quickly to make the lure dart forward - that sudden change in direction often triggers a strike.
Lake Trout
Lake trout are Ontario's deep-water natives and the largest of the char family, regularly hitting 15-40 pounds. These grey-green fish with cream-colored markings prefer the coldest, deepest parts of the lake but will move up during evening hours when water temps drop. Lakers are built for endurance rather than speed, but their size makes up for it - a big laker will give you a long, steady battle. They're excellent eating with firm, flaky meat. Spring and fall produce the best action when they're higher in the water column. Since these fish avoid bright light, our evening trips are perfect timing. One trick I've learned over the years: when jigging for lakers during twilight, use a slower cadence than you would during the day. They seem to prefer a more methodical presentation as light levels drop.
Steelhead Trout
Steelhead are Lake Ontario's ultimate challenge fish - basically rainbow trout that have adapted to big water living. They average 24 inches but can reach 45 inches, with that classic streamlined silver body and black spotting. These fish spend most of their time in deeper water but move up to feed during evening hours when the light fades. What sets steelhead apart is their raw power and endurance - they'll make long runs and fight until the very end. The meat is excellent table fare. Fall through spring are peak seasons, but our evening trips can produce year-round. Pro tip: steelhead are extremely line-shy, so I always recommend dropping down to lighter leaders during low-light conditions. It makes a huge difference in getting these wary fish to commit.
About the Bear Craft
%2F%2Fusers%2F68d642b6-c809-4f57-b879-8b4102e62829%2Fvehicle_picture%2Flakeontariofishingboat-mudaa6z3.jpg&w=1920&q=75)
Vehicle Guest Capacity: 6
Manufacturer Name: Mercury
Maximum Cruising Speed: 35
Number of Engines: 2
Horsepower per Engine: 300
